Why Do Most Investors Underperform the Market?
Final series installment on investment practices that challenge alpha rather than generate it
New readers and free subscribers can access the alpha-achieving QVI Real-Time Stock Picks, a streamlined research checklist, and the full text and audio* of newsletter posts, including archives, by upgrading to a premium subscription that offers exceptional value for the price of a streaming channel. Lock in current rates now, as subscription fees will increase on May 1, 2025. Join the QVI community today.
*Audio is unavailable on some posts.
My new author platform, By David J. Waldron, is now live on Substack. I showcase the revisions and updates of my nonfiction self-help books, offering both text and audio versions for each title. Follow along as I write the manuscript for my upcoming fifth book, Quality Value Investing: How to Pick the Winning Stocks of Enduring Enterprises, in real time. Learn more:
Most private and professional investors consistently underperform the market. Consequently, they pursue new investment strategies and stock-picking ideas because their investment behaviors fail to generate alpha.
In this final installment of the series, Quality Value Investing (QVI) examines investor behaviors that repel alpha instead of generating it.
We will explore further investment behaviors that may undermine a portfolio, concluding with recommended solutions and a summary list of common investor missteps.
They Overlook an Enduring Market Truth
Timing the market by following trends and fads is best deferred to professional traders seeking quick profits.
Occasionally, market timers benefit from luck or intuition, which can permeate financial news and mislead well-intentioned investors regarding market trends. For most, market timing proves ineffective.
The truth is that money-making headliners represent a small fraction of active participants. Many players incur losses, and, like casino gamblers, they often only brag about their wins. This phenomenon illustrates how market fads benefit a fortunate few at the expense of the silent majority of investors, who suffer in their pursuit of substantial capital gains within a single market cycle.
The list of household names that have built fortunes through long-term, quality-driven investments is extensive. However, identifying a celebrity investor who consistently adds to their wealth through quick profits and market timing is nearly impossible.
However, the get-rich-quick narratives from market prognosticators still capture the attention of financial media and their followers.
Why don't more investors adopt Warren Buffett's strategy at Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK.A, BRK.B), which involves purchasing high-quality stocks at reasonable prices and holding them for the long term to leverage the power of compounding?
Remember that Buffett did not reach his pinnacle of becoming a billionaire and a financial celebrity until his 60s. When asked about this phenomenon, I recall that Buffett's answer implied that most investors are not interested in accumulating wealth gradually.
In the short term, speculators buy, sell, or short stocks in reaction to current events, expressing confidence or timidity by casting a vote that can change at a moment's notice due to breaking news, technical chart movements, or an earnings surprise.
Value investing may be too long-term and low-cost for a nearsighted, overly sophisticated financial services industry focused on collecting exorbitant fees and bonuses. Attempting to predict trends, catalysts, and macro events that yield profitable trades resembles a game of chance rather than a legitimate practice.
They believe that trends are their allies. By definition, trend followers overlook underfollowed players in undervalued industries. Nonetheless, following trends or engaging in momentum investing is a temporary strategy that favors shortsighted, speculative trades that fluctuate with market cycles and trends.
It is unimaginable how a disproportionate number of participants in the investment world believe that the current market—whether in a bull, bear, or range-bound—is somehow different, ignoring the fact that business and market cycles come and go randomly. Their preferred differentiator is adopting the latest investment fad to rally around, regardless of the current economic cycle.
They invest in the sophisticated financial models developed by sell-side and buy-side analysts, which attempt to identify the precise difference between the market price and the underlying value of a security.
Overanalyzing or setting price targets can cause individual investors, as well as professionals, to struggle with timing their trades. Furthermore, analysis paralysis during the research of publicly traded companies and their underlying stocks can lead to extreme selling, shorting, or trading put options, as each security carries the potential for unforeseen bad news.
They Subsidize Bonuses for Overly Complex Research
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Quality Value Investing to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.